| Pop Song | Live | Recd | Maps and Legends |
| Yellow River: (Jeff Christie) | 2001 | Vocals by Mike Mills | |
| Yellow Rose Of Texas, The: (Traditional) | 1984 | ||
| Yes, I Am Fucking With You: | 1995 | 1994 | Known as King Of Comedy |
| Yip Song, The: (Robyn Hitchcock) | 1993 | Live 1993: Mike Mills / Robyn Hitchcock | |
| You: | 1995 | 1994 | |
| You Ain't Going Nowhere: (Bob Dylan) | 1988 | Live 1988: The Southern Gentlemen Also live 1991: Bingo Hand Job | |
| You Are The Everything: | 1988 | 1988 | Also live 1991: Bingo Hand Job |
| You Can't Do That: (John Lennon / Paul McCartney) | 1989 | Live 1989: Worst Case Scenarios | |
| You Don't Mean It: (Scott McCaughey) | 2000 | 2000 | Recd 2000: Peter Buck / The Minus 5 Live 2000: Peter Buck / The Minus 5 |
| You Just Have To Be Crazy: (Grant Lee Phillips) | 1995 | Live 1995: Prelude to It's The End Of The World As We Know It | |
| You Mean Everything: (Kevn Kinney) | 1990 | live 1990: Peter Buck / Kevn Kinney | |
| You R Loved: (Victoria Williams) | 1994 | Recd 1994: Mike Mills / Victoria Williams | |
| You Shook Me All Night Long: (A.Young / M.Young / B.Johnson) | 2001 | ||
| You Win Again: (Hank Williams) | 1990 | Live 1990: Peter Buck / The Normaltown Flyers | |
| You Woke Up My Neighbourhood: (Peter Buck / Billy Bragg) | 1991 | Recd 1991: Peter Buck / Michael Stipe / Billy Bragg | |
| You're In The Air: | 1998 | ||
| Your Cheatin' Heart: (Hank Williams) | 1987 | Live 1987: Peter Buck / Raindogs Also live 1990: Peter Buck / The Normaltown Flyers | |
| Your Day Will Come (Parts 1 & 2): (Scott McCaughey) | 2000 | Recd 2000: Peter Buck / The Minus 5 | |
| Your Day Will Come: (Scott McCaughey) | 2002 | 2000 | Recd 2000: Peter Buck / The Minus 5 Live 2002: Peter Buck / The Minus 5 |
| Your Ghost: (Kristin Hersh) | 1994 | Recd 1994: Michael Stipe / Kristin Hersh | |
| Your Truth Our Lies: (Norge / Shrag) | 2001 | Live 2001: Peter Buck / The Minus Tad |